The policy limits under the majority of standard car insurance policies in Ontario is $1,000,000.
Those policy limits don’t stack. That means that if there are more than 1 vehicle involved in a car accident, it doesn’t mean that the Plaintiff has access to $1,000,000 under one policy, plus $1,000,000 under another policy. It means that the policy limits of the claim are limited to $1,000,000; which, if you think about it long and hard, isn’t all that much money in 2025. Will $1,000,000 buy you a home in Toronto proper? Perhaps it will buy you a home outside of Toronto, but after paying all of the closing costs, insurance, taxes, and furnishing the home, you might not be left with a whole lot. In any event, $1,000,000 today, is not the same as $1,000,000 decades ago.
Insurance companies are reluctant to write lump sum cheques for $1,000,000. There are a lot of policy reasons for that. Namely, insurers don’t want their willingness to write the cheque, to come back and create a legal problem.
What do I mean by that?
Let’s assume that a car accident case settles for $1,000,000; and the insurer cuts a lump sum cheque. The Plaintiff then takes his/her share of the settlement funds, and blows through them in a matter of months, weeks, or even days. How can one do that? There are plenty of ways, I can assure you.
Months later, the Plaintiff retains a different personal injury lawyer to bring a claim against the insurance company, along with his/her old personal injury lawyer alleging that the settlement was either not enough (improvident); that it was not placed into a structure (improvident); or that the settlement never should have taken place to begin with.
There might be merit to the Plaintiff’s claim. There might be no merit at all. Nonetheless, after the claim has been made, the insurer and the old personal injury lawyer have to defend it; which is a pain in the you know what; particularly after the parties believe that the claim had settled. After all, the Plaintiff did receive a $1,000,000 which s/he agreed to.